Custom software vs ERP: which is right for a small business

Published on · 4 min read

Short answer

An ERP or off-the-shelf package is faster to get running and works well when your process is standard. Custom software makes sense when your operation is particular, when packages force you to keep separate spreadsheets or when the software is part of what you sell.

Main differences

CriterionERP or off-the-shelf softwareCustom software
Starting pointA product already built for many companiesBuilt around your company's process
FeaturesGeneral; some you won't useOnly what your operation needs
FitYou adapt your process to the softwareThe software adapts to your process
Time to startUsually fasterRequires a development period
CostRecurring license or subscriptionUpfront development investment plus maintenance
GrowthDepends on what the vendor offersEvolves with your needs

When an ERP or off-the-shelf package makes sense

  • Your process is standard, like accounting or payroll, and doesn't set you apart from competitors.
  • You need to start soon and don't have time for a development project.
  • The software must meet regulatory requirements, such as Colombia's electronic invoicing with the DIAN, and a package already includes them.
  • You prefer a lower upfront cost, even if you pay a subscription.

When custom software makes sense

  • The way you operate is particular and is part of what makes you different.
  • Today you work around a package's limits with spreadsheets and manual processes.
  • You need several tools to work together, for example WhatsApp, your CRM and your inventory.
  • You plan to offer the software as a product to your customers, such as a SaaS platform.

A middle path

You don't have to pick just one. Many companies keep a package for the standard parts and build custom software, or automate, whatever the package doesn't cover, connecting both through APIs. That way you avoid replacing what already works.

How to decide

  • Which part of your process is genuinely different from other companies'?
  • How much manual work does your current software create today?
  • How would licenses compare over several years against development and maintenance?
  • Can you start with a small stage and expand later?

Frequently asked questions

Is custom software more expensive than an ERP?

There's no rule. An ERP usually has a lower upfront cost and recurring license payments; custom software needs an upfront development investment plus maintenance. It's worth comparing the total cost over several years and what each option lets you do.

Can I move from spreadsheets to custom software in stages?

Yes. It's common to start with the process that takes the most time and expand later. With weekly progress deliveries you can test each part before moving on to the next.

Related services

Let's talk about your
project

Message us on WhatsApp with what you need. We'll reply with a proposal covering scope, technologies and a work plan, free and with no commitment.